I have signed the nationwide petition to have Edith Cavell depicted on a £2 coin in commemoration of the centenary of the Great War. This follows the Royal Mint’s announcement of a first commemorative coin showing Lord Kitchener pointing his finger on the famous recruitment poster with its motto ‘Your country needs you’.
I am not against the Kitchener coin provided that it doesn’t set the
tone for our nation's World War One commemorations. I understand that there is
to be a series of coins issued during the four years of the centenary. I welcome this, but am sorry that Kitchener was chosen to be the first. Our country does not need him to blaze this trail. While revisionist historians
(and Michael Gove?) may be reassessing the crude, uncritical jingoism popularly associated with his
image and recruiting style, this is not a move that would have endeared itself
to the war poets and others who dared as servicemen to ask uncomfortable but necessary questions
about Britain’s conduct of the war.
Edith Cavell is an altogether different kind of emblem of the Great
War. As a nurse, she understood that her vocation to care and heal could not
make distinctions between victims of war. They all needed what she had to give.
She saved the lives of men on both sides, as the German authorities were quick
to recognise. However, her patriotism was a conviction no less profoundly felt
than Kitchener’s. This was why she helped British and French soldiers escape
occupied Belgium for the safety of the Dutch frontier. For this she was charged
with treason. She did not deny that her actions had helped a ‘hostile power’; she
was executed by firing squad at first light on 12 October 1915.
Her words to her Anglican chaplain on the night before she died have
passed into immortality. But I find them profoundly moving. ‘I realise that
patriotism is not enough. I must have no
hatred or bitterness towards anyone.’ It’s important to read that credo
alongside what she was reported to have said to the German Lutheran chaplain on
the morning of her execution itself: ‘Tell my loved ones…that my soul, as I
believe, is safe, and that I am glad to die for my country’. Pro patria mori: ‘that old lie’, Wilfred
Owen had called it, yet it was Edith Cavell’s truth – honourable because it
understood patriotism within the wider, and primary, context of humanity
To rise above the warmongering rhetoric that so many of her generation
(including Church of England bishops and clergy) espoused called for courage
and resolve. I believe that her restatement of patriotic love-of-country as part
of love-for-humanity makes her a truly universal figure of the Great War. Those
who were our enemies in world war will be able to honour this too. She can
become a true symbol of integrity and conscience in warfare where, as we know,
truth is always the first casualty. More than that, she can stand for the
possibility of reconciliation, building a society in which human beings are aspiring
to renounce hatred and bitterness and learning the more excellent way of love.
I am saying that Edith Cavell can help us to remember the Great War well. This matters because
we only learn from our history if we can reach back into our corporate memory and converse with it intelligently. This means bringing critical insights to bear on the ways we tell our story. It's a complex, subtle interpretative task. Some recent right-wing commentary on the educational challenges of the centenary does not seem to have realised this yet.
So I hope, with thousands of others, that we shall see this
great Englishwoman soon honoured on a coin of the realm. If you would like to
add your name to the petition, you can find it at www.change.org.
- Pilgrim, priest and ponderer. European living in Northumberland. I have been a parish priest, theological educator and cathedral precentor; then Dean of Sheffield 1995-2003 and Dean of Durham 2003-2015.**** I blog on faith, society, church matters, the North East, European issues, the arts, travel and anything else that intrigues.**** My main blog is at http://northernwoolgatherer.blogspot.com.**** My sermons and addresses are at: http://northernambo.blogspot.com.**** Blogs during my time as Dean of Durham: http://decanalwoolgatherer.blogspot.com.